top of page
Search

Freight Pulse & Law Update: A $24 Million Line Item Vanishes and a Contract Claim Survives (Nov. 21, 2026)

Writer: Lanta LLC
Lanta LLC
15 hours ago
2 min read

Two freight liability rulings this week turned on statutory text and contract language, not sympathy. One cut $24 million from a wrongful-death verdict; the other let a stolen-load contract claim proceed and threw out the negligence theories.

What did a Michigan appeals court remove from a $78.5 million verdict?

The Michigan Court of Appeals ruled Nov. 20 that a wrongful-death award cannot include preimpact fright and shock, vacating that part of a roughly $78.5 million judgment against a motor carrier. It ordered a retrial on pain and suffering only and affirmed the rest, including admitted liability.

  • The crash: a tractor-trailer rear-ended a stopped car on I-75 in 2018 at over 50 mph, killing two

  • The verdict: about $68 million from a Wayne County jury, roughly $78.5 million with interest

  • Removed: $24 million for preimpact fright and shock, not a listed category

  • Second problem: an undisclosed pain-and-suffering expert, with no defense deposition

Why did an Arizona court let a stolen-load contract claim survive?

A federal judge let a shipper add a breach-of-contract claim against a logistics provider in a cargo theft suit, holding it enforces privately agreed delivery terms and is not preempted. Negligence claims were denied.

  • The load: 1,440 hair dryers worth $466,315.20, stolen in the provider's custody

  • The defense: it brokered the load, not hauled it, so Carmack liability should not apply

  • What survived: contract claims, a backup if that broker defense wins

  • What did not: negligence and negligent hiring, because theft claims sit outside the safety exception

What is the Mid-Atlantic angle?

The Federal Highway Administration opened a $100 million Congestion Relief Grant program through Dec. 17 for metros over one million people, covering Baltimore, Philadelphia and Washington and their freight corridors.

  • Eligible uses: traffic management systems, HOV lanes, expanded express service

  • The funding notice, not the announcement, defines which freight bottleneck work qualifies

Where does this land on your board?

Both rulings move money on documentation. For supply chain management companies, vague delivery terms and thin custody records become someone else's argument later. FlowOps by Lanta is Lanta Logistics' proprietary, operator-built logistics software: $99 a month flat, unlimited SKUs, 20+ modules, patent-pending Agentic AI and real-time visibility across every touchpoint. Compare at https://wms.lantallc.com/compare or start at https://wms.lantallc.com.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page